Murder-Suicide Med For Depression 2010-04-04 North Carolina Father Kills his Two Children, his Wife & Himself: On Depression Med for 16 Days

http://ssristories.com/show.php?item=4101 & http://web.archive.org/web/20130202041043/http://ssristories.com/show.php?item=4101

Summary:

Paragraphs five and six read:  "His first visit to Mecklenburg's mental health center came Feb. 28, records show."

" 'I need some help,'  he told a nurse during a two-hour evaluation."

Paragraphs 16 and 17 read:  "A nurse noted that he later denied wanting to harm himself or others. In a mental exam, she found his mood, appearance, thought processes and speech appropriate. She found none of 10 danger signs that he was a threat, and a doctor called it a  'low complexity'  case."

"So they sent Chapman home, with reading materials about community resources and a prescription for medication to treat anxiety and depression."

Paragraphs 19 and twenty read:  "Two weeks later, Kenny and Nateesha Chapman had a screaming match."

"The kids heard the arguing that Monday night, March 15."

Paragraphs 38 and 39 read:  "He increased the dosage of anti-anxiety medication and gave Chapman a pamphlet on healthy sleep. Chapman was instructed to make an appointment for himself and pursue couple's therapy.

Chapman left the hospital around 6 a.m. on Tuesday, March 16.


http://www.heraldonline.com/2010/04/04/2065093_p2/records-show-nc-man-sought-help.html

Published: Sunday, Apr. 04, 2010 / Updated: Sunday, Apr. 04, 2010 08:50 AM


Records show N.C. man sought help before killing his wife, two children, himself

By Cleve R. Wootson Jr., Ely Portillo and April Bethea, The Charlotte Observer

But records show the Chapmans struggled to make it on $800 a month. They got food stamps and Medicaid. And their landlord began eviction proceedings three times.

Last September, someone called Mecklenburg's Department of Social Services. The agency didn't open a case on the family, officials said, because the information provided in the complaint "did not meet the legal definition of abuse, neglect or dependency."

'I need some help'

Chapman stopped going to AA last December, he told doctors.

His first visit to Mecklenburg's mental health center came Feb. 28, records show.

"I need some help," he told a nurse during a two-hour evaluation.

He was drinking, he reported. He felt depressed and was sleeping just three to four hours a night. He had been fighting with his wife and was having thoughts of "harming" her, a medical screener wrote in his records.

The screener circled the word "homicidal" in describing his problem.

He also had access to guns, he reported. Chapman had a rifle at home, and a .45-caliber pistol.

"I feel like hurting someone or myself," he wrote in a questionnaire. "I've been fighting with my spouse a lot and words that she said to me that have made me angry...I don't feel like myself."

It was a "chronically volatile relationship," a doctor wrote, with verbal and physical conflicts.

Chapman also thought about harming animals, he said.

A nurse wrote that Chapman "wants to get into the system." He was new to Charlotte and lacked social support, he said. He wanted "to talk to someone and get a solution that helps me," he wrote on the questionnaire.

During the evaluation, records show Chapman saw at least four different clinicians, including a psychiatrist.

A nurse noted that he later denied wanting to harm himself or others. In a mental exam, she found his mood, appearance, thought processes and speech appropriate. She found none of 10 danger signs that he was a threat, and a doctor called it a "low complexity" case.

So they sent Chapman home, with reading materials about community resources and a prescription for medication to treat anxiety and depression.

Chapman was to call back within a day to make an appointment for therapy. His family was getting ready to move, and records don't say whether he followed up.

A final plea

Two weeks later, Kenny and Nateesha Chapman had a screaming match.

The kids heard the arguing that Monday night, March 15.

Kenny left the house and soon appeared again at the mental health center's emergency room.

It was 2 a.m. on March 16.

"WANTS TO HURT HIS WIFE," a staffer wrote as Chapman's reason for coming in.

They launched a series of interviews, a mental and physical exam, and observed him for the next four hours.

They checked vital signs and noted that his appearance, concentration, thought processes and orientation were normal.

A nurse marked his mood as "sad."

Chapman still had trouble sleeping, little appetite and had lost weight.

"I want to kill my wife," he told staff. He was having hallucinations, he said: "I see shadows of people every day."

Chapman said he felt stressed about his finances, issues with his oldest child, low self-esteem and feelings of inadequacy, a nurse wrote.

Again, records show, he reported that he had access to firearms.

And again, he saw at least four clinicians, including a psychiatrist.

He thought his medicine from the last visit was helping "some," although experts say such drugs can take weeks to become effective.

In separate interviews later in his visit, Chapman told a nurse and a doctor that he wasn't going to harm anyone.

The nurse wrote that Chapman "denies" wanting to kill his wife, but "I'm tired of her BS."

On a risk assessment form, she checked "No" for the 10 danger signs. But she noted he'd had homicidal thoughts earlier. It's unclear whether anyone informed his wife or social service agencies about Chapman's comments.

His doctor wrote that Chapman said he could "refrain from harm to self and others." The doctor felt Chapman had a "depressive disorder."

During the hospital visit, a staffer checked on Chapman at least seven times - every half hour - and each time marked "no aggression noted" on a Violence-Aggression Checklist. He was calm, according to staffers. For 45 minutes, he sat quietly with his eyes closed.

The hospital decided to send Chapman home. A doctor categorized his ER visit as "moderate complexity."

Had the doctor found Chapman's situation more threatening, he could have asked Chapman to voluntarily go into the hospital or had him involuntarily admitted as an emergency.

He increased the dosage of anti-anxiety medication and gave Chapman a pamphlet on healthy sleep. Chapman was instructed to make an appointment for himself and pursue couple's therapy.

Chapman left the hospital around 6 a.m. on Tuesday, March 16.

Anger explodes

Back at home, the school day began as always. The kids went to school and day care.

But while they were gone, police say Chapman suffocated his wife in the family's old apartment on Via Romano Drive.

That night, while Chapman's first-born daughter, now 10, was downstairs with her 2-year-old brother, she heard her older stepsister screaming upstairs.

Police say Chapman stabbed 13-year-old Na'Jhae Parker, and suffocated his 1-year-old daughter, Nakyiah.

He locked their bodies in an upstairs bedroom, according to police, who say they gleaned details about the killings from conversations with the 10-year-old girl.

For two weeks after the killings, Chapman sent his surviving daughter to school and son to day care.

Terrified her father might kill them next, police say, the girl told nobody what had happened. And at home, she acted as if she suspected nothing.

She told investigators her dad didn't talk about their missing family members. He'd only ask occasionally if she smelled something.

Once, she said, her father held a gun to her head but told her he decided not to kill her because she was his first-born daughter. He also spared her baby brother - Chapman's first-born son.

Chapman also killed the family dogs, the girl told police.

When family members phoned for Chapman's wife, police say, he would claim she was busy, at work, or not available by cell phone.

On March 19, three days after the killings, a family friend told police he feared Chapman might be suicidal because of goodbye messages on Facebook. But when police went to check on him, officers went to the old apartment - where Nateesha's body lay inside - and got no answer.

At the new apartment, Chapman deflected calls from school and day care staff asking about Na'Jhae and Nakyiah, saying the children were home sick.

This past Monday, an uncle again sent police to check on the Chapmans - and this time Kenny Chapman met them at the door.

When officers asked for his wife, he called out to her and invited officers inside. Police were suspicious and stayed outside, and soon the two surviving kids came running out.

Chapman fired a shot through the front door at police. Then he fatally shot himself.

Burials this week

Four funerals are planned for this week. Nateesha Chapman and her two daughters will be buried in New York, Kenny Chapman in New Jersey.

The two surviving children are in DSS custody, placed with relatives. The 10-year-old is getting therapy and visits from loved ones. Her baby brother clings to her.

Kenny's mom and stepdad, the Cosbys, want custody.

The girl is bright and makes good grades in school, Cosby says. Friends say she likes math and ballet, and is the only kid they know who watches the evening news.

The Cosbys pray she can recover and begin again to pursue her dreams.

"She has a schedule," Cosby says. "She wants to grow up, finish college, get her master's degree and go to the Senate, then become president.

"After she's been president, she wants to leave politics and have a child."

Cosby wishes his son had gotten more help.

"In a community the size of Charlotte, there should be resources to help whoever needs it. I'm not going to blame anyone, though."

Researcher Maria David and staff writers Liz Chandler, Karen Garloch and Lisa Hammersly contributed.